Toyota Supra
When shopping for a new vehicle, resale value is often one of the last considerations for most buyers. While depreciation is an unavoidable reality, it tends to feel like a distant concern.
Understandably, consumers tend to prioritize factors like reliability, performance, and fuel efficiency over a car’s projected worth a few years down the line. However, taking depreciation into account early on can serve as a valuable strategy when the time comes to trade up.
10. Toyota Venza
Average New Price: $35,070
Average Value After 3 Years: $26,810
Depreciation: $8,260 (23.55%)
Kicking off the list is the Toyota Venza, a hybrid crossover that delivers an appealing mix of design, technology, and efficiency. For years, it served as an alternative to the RAV4, with its last generation standing out for its 4-cylinder hybrid powertrain producing 219 horsepower.
Despite its merits, the Venza struggled to distinguish itself from the RAV4 Hybrid and was eventually replaced by the Crown Signia SUV. Still, with just under 25% depreciation over three years, owners will find themselves pleasantly surprised by its strong resale value.
9. Toyota RAV4
Average New Price: $28,675
Average Value After 3 Years: $22,212
Depreciation: $6,463 (22.54%)
Since the Venza has long been viewed as a sibling to the RAV4, it’s fitting that the latter edges it out slightly in resale value.
The RAV4 is a consistent top-seller, thanks to its impressive combination of reliability, practicality, comfort, and performance, especially in the hybrid variant, which also delivers excellent fuel economy. While its styling might not appeal to everyone, its strong reputation ensures that it retains value better than most of its competitors.
8. Acura Integra
Average New Price: $31,800
Average Value After 3 Years: $25,031
Depreciation: $6,769 (21.29%)
The appearance of the Acura Integra on this list may come as a surprise, but according to Zutobi’s metrics, it boasts the eighth-best resale value. Critics may label it as a gussied-up Civic Si, but that’s not necessarily a drawback.
The Civic Si has long been lauded for its performance, and the Integra builds on that foundation with added style and premium features for just a bit more. While the 320-horsepower Type S trim is likely to retain its value best, the entire lineup is a safe investment.
7. Toyota Corolla Cross
Average New Price: $23,860
Average Value After 3 Years: $18,870
Depreciation: $4,990 (20.91%)
The Toyota Corolla Cross is one of the most well-rounded vehicles in its segment. With a starting price just over $24,000 for the 2025 model, it offers excellent value.
Top trims like the Hybrid XSE can push the price past $31,000, but even the base model serves as a competent and efficient commuter. The real standout is the Hybrid trim, which adds all-wheel drive, 196 horsepower, and an impressive 42 mpg combined for just around $28,000. It’s no surprise this crossover holds its value so well.
6. Toyota Corolla
Average New Price: $22,050
Average Value After 3 Years: $17,439
Depreciation: $4,611 (20.91%)
Continuing the trend, the Toyota Corolla, officially the best-selling car of all time, earns its place on the list with strong resale figures.
With nearly 60 years of global popularity behind it, the Corolla remains a symbol of dependability and value. The latest generation, especially the hybrid model, offers a compelling package of features and efficiency. While it might not be the most thrilling vehicle to drive, what it lacks in excitement it makes up for in long-term value.
5. Ford Ranger
Average New Price: $32,670
Average Value After 3 Years: $25,908
Depreciation: $6,762 (20.70%)
Breaking up Toyota’s streak is the Ford Ranger, which saw a significant refresh. Since returning to the U.S. market, the Ranger has consistently delivered as a capable midsize pickup, although some felt its styling was a bit bland.
The update addresses those concerns, bringing a more modern design along with performance and utility enhancements. Notably, the new Ranger Raptor trim offers serious off-road credentials and aims to compete with the Toyota TRD Pro and Chevy Colorado ZR2.
4. Toyota Sienna
Average New Price: $37,685
Average Value After 3 Years: $30,330
Depreciation: $7,355 (19.52%)
The Toyota Sienna continues to be a standout in the shrinking minivan market. With a strong reputation for practicality, efficiency, and reliability, it delivers excellent resale value.
Offered exclusively as a hybrid producing 245 horsepower, the Sienna comes with either front- or all-wheel drive. It may not be fast, but it offers a smooth and comfortable ride—qualities that are top priorities for minivan buyers.
3. Subaru BRZ
Average New Price: $30,195
Average Value After 3 Years: $24,356
Depreciation: $5,839 (19.34%)
The Subaru BRZ ranks third for resale value, even though its sibling, the Toyota GR86, did not make the list. That’s especially intriguing given that the GR86 has reportedly outsold the BRZ by a ratio of seven to one. This relative rarity may be helping the BRZ retain more of its value.
Enthusiasts continue to appreciate Subaru’s performance credentials, and with limited editions like the Series. Purple model on the horizon for 2025, its appeal and value should remain strong.
2. Toyota Supra
Average New Price: $46,440
Average Value After 3 Years: $37,857
Depreciation: $8,583 (18.48%)
With a name that carries serious weight in automotive circles, the Toyota Supra earns its place near the top of the list. The current GR Supra may have defied some expectations, being heavily influenced by BMW, but it delivers a thrilling driving experience.
Its turbocharged B58 engine and engaging dynamics have already earned it a cult following, and limited editions like the A90 Final Edition are expected to command premium prices on the collector market in the years ahead.
1. Toyota Tacoma
Average New Price: $33,700
Average Value After 3 Years: $27,880
Depreciation: $5,820 (17.27%)
Claiming the number one spot is the Toyota Tacoma. If you’re familiar with this truck’s legendary durability and loyal fanbase, this won’t be surprising. Known for its rugged build and long-term dependability, the Tacoma is the top choice for buyers looking for a pickup that won’t let them down.
Given how fiercely loyal truck owners can be, it’s no shock that the Tacoma retains value exceptionally well, losing less than 18% over three years. Whether the latest generation will live up to this legacy remains to be seen, but the track record is promising.
About the Author
